%% SCRAP: archive/operations/refinement/capa
%% SOURCE: docs/working/archive/operations/refinement/capa.adoc
%% STATUS: OBSOLETE
%% FITS: none
%% EDITORIAL: lifted — prose rewritten to press voice; adoc syntax translated

\section*{C\,$\leftrightarrow$\,Isabelle Refinement Defect Tracking (Obsolete)}

Three defects were logged against the planned C\,$\leftrightarrow$\,Isabelle
refinement program as of 2025-10-30:

\begin{itemize}
  \item \textbf{DEFECT-001}: Stack push error handling---C implementation
        allowed silent stack overflow; Isabelle model required explicit bounds
        check with error propagation.
  \item \textbf{DEFECT-002}: Return stack misalignment---C implementation used
        a pointer-based return stack incompatible with the Isabelle inductive
        model.
  \item \textbf{DEFECT-003}: Instruction dispatch---C used a jump table;
        Isabelle model defined dispatch as a mathematical function without
        equivalent performance semantics.
\end{itemize}

All three defects were recorded as \textsc{open}. The refinement program that
generated them was never executed; formal verification took a different
architectural form. These defect records are obsolete.
